Under $5 Plugs

1 - 24 of 527 products
Sort by
Sort by
Clear Acrylic Black Anchor Saddle Plug Set 6mm to 20mmClear Acrylic Black Anchor Saddle Plug Set 6mm to 20mm
Clear Acrylic Black Anchor Saddle Plug Set 6mm to 20mm
From $3.99$9.99
Clear Acrylic Optical Illusion Saddle Plug 14mm to 25mmClear Acrylic Optical Illusion Saddle Plug 14mm to 25mm
Clear Acrylic Optical Illusion Saddle Plug 14mm to 25mm
From $4.99$8.99
Clear Gem Angel Wing and White Rose Flower Single Flare Dangle Plug Sizes 6mm to 16mmClear Gem Angel Wing and White Rose Flower Single Flare Dangle Plug Sizes 6mm to 16mm
Clear Gem Angel Wing and White Rose Flower Single Flare Dangle Plug Sizes 6mm to 16mm
4.5 star rating4 reviews
From $4.00$15.99
Thin Flexible White Silicone Tunnel Plug Set 6mm to 25mmThin Flexible White Silicone Tunnel Plug Set 6mm to 25mm
Thin Flexible White Silicone Tunnel Plug Set 6mm to 25mm
5 star rating23 reviews
From $4.99$13.99
Green Blue Acrylic Mermaid Scale Straight Plug Set 14 Gauge to 8 GaugeGreen Blue Acrylic Mermaid Scale Straight Plug Set 14 Gauge to 8 Gauge
Green Blue Acrylic Mermaid Scale Straight Plug Set 14 Gauge to 8 Gauge
4.8 star rating13 reviews
$3.99$27.99
Rose Gold Tone Anodized Steel Double Flare Tunnel Plug Set 4mm to 16mmRose Gold Tone Anodized Steel Double Flare Tunnel Plug Set 4mm to 16mm
Rose Gold Tone Anodized Steel Double Flare Tunnel Plug Set 4mm to 16mm
4.9 star rating67 reviews
From $1.99$19.99
Gold Plated Southwestern Stone Age Double Flare Plug Set 2 Gauge to 22mmGold Plated Southwestern Stone Age Double Flare Plug Set 2 Gauge to 22mm
Gold Plated Southwestern Stone Age Double Flare Plug Set 2 Gauge to 22mm
4.9 star rating30 reviews
From $1.99$8.99
Green Anodized Steel Double Flare Tunnel Plug Set 4mm-16mmGreen Anodized Steel Double Flare Tunnel Plug Set 4mm-16mm
Green Anodized Steel Double Flare Tunnel Plug Set 4mm-16mm
4.9 star rating47 reviews
From $1.99$7.99
Rose Quartz Faceted Single Flare Plug Set 6mm to 25mm SizesRose Quartz Faceted Single Flare Plug Set 6mm to 25mm Sizes
Rose Quartz Faceted Single Flare Plug Set 6mm to 25mm Sizes
4.8 star rating18 reviews
From $1.99$25.99
Southwestern Pinwheel Flower Double Flare Plug Set Set 2 Gauge to 22mmSouthwestern Pinwheel Flower Double Flare Plug Set Set 2 Gauge to 22mm
Southwestern Pinwheel Flower Double Flare Plug Set Set 2 Gauge to 22mm
4.9 star rating21 reviews
From $1.99$8.99
Double Pink Imitation Opal Dangle Plug Sizes 5mm to 1 InchDouble Pink Imitation Opal Dangle Plug Sizes 5mm to 1 Inch
Double Pink Imitation Opal Dangle Plug Sizes 5mm to 1 Inch
4.2 star rating14 reviews
From $1.76$1.99
Clear 2 in 1 Interchangeable Screw Fit Plug and Taper SetClear 2 in 1 Interchangeable Screw Fit Plug and Taper Set
Clear 2 in 1 Interchangeable Screw Fit Plug and Taper Set
4.5 star rating17 reviews
From $1.99$7.99
Organic Hand Carved Wood Nautical Anchor Hanger Plug Set 4mm to 10mmOrganic Hand Carved Wood Nautical Anchor Hanger Plug Set 4mm to 10mm
Organic Hand Carved Wood Nautical Anchor Hanger Plug Set 4mm to 10mm
4.5 star rating2 reviews
From $1.99$12.99
Acrylic Pink and White Marbled Saddle Plug 6 Gauge to 1 InchAcrylic Pink and White Marbled Saddle Plug 6 Gauge to 1 Inch
Acrylic Pink and White Marbled Saddle Plug 6 Gauge to 1 Inch
4.9 star rating11 reviews
From $0.99$1.99
Angry Dragon Double Flare Tunnel Plug Set 6mm to 25mmAngry Dragon Double Flare Tunnel Plug Set 6mm to 25mm
Angry Dragon Double Flare Tunnel Plug Set 6mm to 25mm
4.7 star rating43 reviews
From $1.99$8.99
Black Acrylic Red Flashy Tire Rim Saddle Plug 2 Gauge to 20mmBlack Acrylic Red Flashy Tire Rim Saddle Plug 2 Gauge to 20mm
Black Acrylic Red Flashy Tire Rim Saddle Plug 2 Gauge to 20mm
5 star rating1 review
From $0.99$1.99
White Acrylic Red Marigold Insert Saddle Plug Set Available in Sizes 12mm to 26mmWhite Acrylic Red Marigold Insert Saddle Plug Set Available in Sizes 12mm to 26mm
White Acrylic Red Marigold Insert Saddle Plug Set Available in Sizes 12mm to 26mm
4.8 star rating4 reviews
From $1.99$7.99
White Acrylic Pineapple Single Flare Plug Set Available in Sizes 3mm to 16mmWhite Acrylic Pineapple Single Flare Plug Set Available in Sizes 3mm to 16mm
White Acrylic Pineapple Single Flare Plug Set Available in Sizes 3mm to 16mm
4.8 star rating16 reviews
From $1.99$10.99
White Acrylic Silver Flashy Tire Rim Saddle Plug 2 Gauge to 20mmWhite Acrylic Silver Flashy Tire Rim Saddle Plug 2 Gauge to 20mm
White Acrylic Silver Flashy Tire Rim Saddle Plug 2 Gauge to 20mm
4.7 star rating3 reviews
From $0.92$1.99
White Acrylic Grey Flashy Tire Rim Saddle Plug 2 Gauge to 20mmWhite Acrylic Grey Flashy Tire Rim Saddle Plug 2 Gauge to 20mm
White Acrylic Grey Flashy Tire Rim Saddle Plug 2 Gauge to 20mm
4.5 star rating4 reviews
From $0.92$1.99
Black Acrylic Silver Flashy Tire Rim Saddle Plug 2 Gauge to 20mmBlack Acrylic Silver Flashy Tire Rim Saddle Plug 2 Gauge to 20mm
Black Acrylic Silver Flashy Tire Rim Saddle Plug 2 Gauge to 20mm
4.5 star rating2 reviews
From $0.92$3.99
Clear Pink Acrylic Wish on a Star Saddle Plug 2 Gauge to 20mmClear Pink Acrylic Wish on a Star Saddle Plug 2 Gauge to 20mm
Clear Pink Acrylic Wish on a Star Saddle Plug 2 Gauge to 20mm
5 star rating3 reviews
From $0.99$1.99
Clear Light Blue Acrylic Wish on a Star Saddle Plug 2 Gauge to 20mmClear Light Blue Acrylic Wish on a Star Saddle Plug 2 Gauge to 20mm
Clear Light Blue Acrylic Wish on a Star Saddle Plug 2 Gauge to 20mm
4.8 star rating5 reviews
From $0.99$1.99
White Acrylic Pink Flashy Tire Rim Saddle Plug 2 Gauge to 20mmWhite Acrylic Pink Flashy Tire Rim Saddle Plug 2 Gauge to 20mm
White Acrylic Pink Flashy Tire Rim Saddle Plug 2 Gauge to 20mm
5 star rating3 reviews
From $0.99$1.99