• Mystery Box

Mystery Box

Rated 4.6 out of 5
Based on 28 reviews
What will be in your box? It remains up to chance. Like Madonna says, "Life is a mystery."

Added to your cart!

View cart or continue shopping.

All of these items are very close to perfect, but have some special character or quirk that set them apart.

In truth, we genuinely love items that are ever so slightly funky, but still beautiful and functional. If the same goes for you, this is a great chance to roll the dice and get some beautiful products at the best price we'll ever offer. 

The Standard Mystery is a collection of a minimum of three items and will contain at least one item of $65+ value as an anchor and the value of the items will be at least $175 retail.

The Bigger Mystery is a collection of a minimum of three items and will contain at least one item of $98+ as an anchor and the value of the items will be at least $290 retail.

Very limited quantities, so when they're gone, they're gone.

Please note: Mystery Boxes are final sale and are not eligible for discount code use.

Write a Review
average rating 4.6 out of 5
Based on 28 reviews
  • 5 Stars
    21 Reviews
  • 4 Stars
    5 Reviews
  • 3 Stars
    1 Review
  • 2 Stars
    0 Reviews
  • 1 Star
    1 Review
93% of reviewers would recommend this product to a friend
Customer photos and videos
Open user-uploaded photo and review in a modal Open user-uploaded photo and review in a modal
28 Reviews
Reviewed by Nikolaus Z.
Verified Buyer
I recommend this product
Rated 4 out of 5
Review posted

A fun deal

This is the second box I have ordered. Last year’s box was superb this box was not as awesome but I certainly still felt I got my money’s worth.

While I recommend the box to those who don’t mind a surprise, if you need to know exactly what you will receive, this might not be for you.

But overall, if you know the brand and trust their products you know you will get fine Craighill wares at an excellent price.

The photo is of my puppy thinking the Venn puzzle was a toy for her. She tried to pick it up and lost interest after a moment. But this came in last year’s box and is my favorite puzzle!

Loading...
Was this helpful?
Reviewed by Nazri N.
Verified Buyer
I recommend this product
Rated 5 out of 5
Review posted

Lucked out on basically everything in the box!

The random nature of the box is obviously part of its mystique, but that adds to the excitement of opening it up. I saved mine as a reward for completing a project and totally lucked out on some items I loved (and in some cases, didn't know I wanted). A match striker, the Invar cubic inch, and the bookends. Score.

Everything else was a bonus at that point, and even the stuff I wouldn't use is readily giftable. Can barely notice any imperfections. Very tempted to pick up another one after I finish my current WIP!

Loading...
Image by Nazri N.
Was this helpful?
Reviewed by Wes R.
Verified Buyer
I recommend this product
Rated 5 out of 5
Review posted

Awesome. Quality I have come to expect t from every order and every item.

I have come to expect the level of craftsmanship and quality from every item and the mystery box didn't disappoint. If I had to find anything to complain about it would be simply that they sent me a match stick holder that only works with craighill matches, but didn't send any matches lol.

You guys are awesome. Keep it up

Loading...
Was this helpful?

Craighill

Hi Wes!
The Match Striker works with "Strike Anywhere" matches, which can be found at local hardware stores. Thanks so much for your review, happy to hear you're enjoying the Mystery Box!

Reviewed by Justin S.
Verified Buyer
Rated 3 out of 5
Review posted

Mystery

Quality of items was good, but few will be used by me.

Loading...
Was this helpful?
Reviewed by Peter T.
Verified Buyer
I recommend this product
Rated 5 out of 5
Review posted

Nice boxful of items

My second purchase of a mystery box. Lots of nice items. Condition of items seem close to perfect. Definitely a good value.

Loading...
Was this helpful?